A History of Native America

Maeve Kane

mkane2@albany.edu

maevekane.net/hill

First half

  • Native America is a big place!
  • what is a nation?
  • Recognition status today

YES:

  • Native, Native American, American Indian, Indian, First Nations, First Peoples
  • Alaska Native, Hawaiian Native, Inuit, Aboriginal
  • Indigenous, people of color
  • specific national or tribal designation always preferred (ie, Iroquois, Haudenosaunee, Mohawk, Kanien'kehá:ka)
  • "Nation" preferable to "tribe,": "the Oneida Nation," rather than "the Oneida tribe" unless specified in self-designated official name, ie Couer D'Alene Tribe
  • "Mohawk people" rather than "the Mohawk"

NO:

  • squ*w, redsk*n, Eskimo/Eskimaux, colored people
reservations
reservations
languages
languages

Sovereignty

  • what is a nation?
  • how are the boundaries of a nation defined?
  • without citizenship, how do you define "American"?

SOVEREIGNTY

  • who exercises power in an area?
  • from God; from collective agreement; from relationship to land
  • existed before contact: treaty rights are not "given"
  • treaties are between two equal nations
  • usufruct vs. fee simple rights

POWERS OF SOVEREIGNTY

  • taxation and public funds spending
  • defining citizens and their rights
  • law enforcement
  • government to government relations
  • sole and exclusive authority
  • independent internal decision making

SETTLER COLONIALISM

  • US, Canada, Australia, New Zealand
  • land is required for population expansion and resources
  • Native people hold land
  • Native people do not consent to be governed
  • "logic of erasure"
  • connection to slavery: land & labor

FEDERAL RECOGNITION

  • must comprise a distinct community
  • have existed as a community from historical times
  • must have retained a considerable measure of Indian culture
  • must have political influence over its members
  • must have membership criteria
  • must have membership of individuals who descend from a distinct tribe and are not members of any other tribe

DOMESTIC DEPENDENT NATIONS

  • cannot have independent foreign relations
  • limited powers of sovereignty
  • federal trust relationship
  • "Indians not taxed"
  • within but not part of American nation

Second half

  • Legal definitions
  • Biological definitions
  • Cultural definitions
  • Political definitions
  • The problem of "authenticity"

Biology

CDIB
CDIB

Biology

  • social security card and birth certificate
  • mother's affidavit of birth
  • "full-form" birth or death certificate for parents, grandparents, great grandparents, and great great grandparents (30 people)
  • enrollment numbers for great grandparents and great great grandparents
  • NOT a DNA test

Biology: WHY NOT DNA?

  • no DNA for specific tribes
  • enrollment and recognition tribe-based
  • Y-chromosome haplogroup inheritence
  • Y-chromosome haplogroups distinct but not universal
  • mtDNA in common with Asian and Polynesian groups

Cultural: MASPEE RECOGNITION

  • the "rich Indian" problem
  • who defines "authenticity"?
  • Trump-funded genealogy research: 1993 lawsuit, 2007 recognition & 2017 court filing
  • 2017 BIA rules change: tribe may not re-petition after denial

Political: US CITIZENSHIP VS "INDIAN"

  • US citizenship purely political: anyone can become a member
  • "Indian" is political, historical, biological, and/or cultural depending on situation
  • conflation of political rights with race and/or culture

The Authenticity Problem

The Authenticity Problem