Most broadly, my work is about how people make their identities. To do that, I look at clothing, because clothing is the interface between the self, the community, and the outside world. As a choice made everyday, clothing is a productive lens through which to examine how individuals choose to position themselves in different spaces; how race, gender and communities are socially constructed and perceived; and how tensions over changes in religion, consumption, and labor are worked out on a daily basis. As a site of contestation over civility and therefore political legitimacy from the seventeenth to the nineteenth century (and in the present), clothing in all its forms is inherently political. A white linen shirt painted red and red cotton cloth remade as traditional regalia had multiple political meanings for the Native women who made and wore them.
Clothing’s many social meanings makes it a useful way of looking at the formation of racial, gender, and national identities in communities which don’t have a lot of written documentation. In my case, this is the Six Nations Iroquois of what is now New York, which includes the Mohawk, Oneida, Onondaga, Cayuga, Seneca, and Tuscarora. Until the American Revolution, the Iroquois Confederacy was the single largest military and territorial power in eastern North America, though the individual nations of the Iroquois Confederacy functioned more like the separate nations of the EU or the UN than like states within the US. That means that there were important and sometimes very large political and social differences between the Six Nations which I explore in my book project, but today for the sake of time I’ll be speaking broadly about the Iroquois as a cultural and social group, with some comparisons between the Mohawk in the east near Albany and the Seneca in the west near Buffalo, and between the Iroquois and the nearby non-Iroquois Mahican.
I am not Native—my work is academic and I’m not part of the communities I work with. I got interested in the question of how clothing is used to perform identity during a college internship in a museum costume department, but I came to my current project because of images like this one—an anonymous, nameless woman with a baby. I started this project as a comparative one. I was going to look at how white, black, and Native women used clothing and domestic labor in early America to articulate ideas about race, gender, and identity. But as I began the project, I was struck by how different much of the accepted wisdom on Native women was from recent scholarship on white and black women’s labor. The image here typifies many of the problems of writing the history of Native people and especially Native women. This watercolor is probably mid-eighteenth century, probably French, probably of a Mohawk woman; there’s no other detail, even though this is the only image of an Iroquois woman, rather than a generically Indian woman, before 1800. This lack of context, lack of specificity, and reliance on the lens of European observers is typical of much of the material scholars of Native history have to work with. How we interpret why she’s wearing what she’s wearing is important, because it’s one of the few ways we as historians have of getting at not just the history of how Europeans viewed Native people, but the history of Native people themselves. How we interpret her clothing I’ll return to in a bit.
[SLIDE 2 – NMAI]
This image is of an exhibit at the National Museum of the American Indian in New York City—it’s a very beautiful piece if you have a chance to go down and see it in person. It’s a man’s outfit from the same period, and I was kind of loitering around it last fall when two women stopped to look at it.
“Look at that!” one of the women said. “You could wear that with a pair of jeans today and look pretty cute!” And it’s true, both the shirt and the moccasins were very on trend. “But where,” the first woman wondered, “did the Indians get the clothes from? How did they get the beads and the fabric?”
The other woman thought about this for a bit. And then she said, “Well, I suppose they sold all their land for it.”
It’s not very fair to poke fun at a couple of museum visitors, but their exchange reflects the popular and even the academic understanding of Native trade for European goods: that it was for frivolous things, the kind of fast fashion we might now buy from Forever 21, that it replaced “traditional” or “real” Native clothing, and that it was purchased at the cost of land and political sovereignty. The current scholarship of Native trade and economic history in early America often overstates both the role of violence in Native economic life and the damage done to Native communities by trade with Europeans. Based largely on the experience of Native groups in New England and the Southeast, this scholarship mistakes effect for cause. It argues that sustained engagement with European trade caused Native groups to engage in a spiral of market-driven hunting that fueled violence and economic dependence, and that inevitably led to colonialism.
The Iroquois were unique in some ways which allowed them to keep control of their lands for longer than some other eastern Native groups. However, the Iroquois experience can actually be used to examine the history of trade and Native political economy more broadly in early America because their longer experience of trade without violence shows that Native groups could and did engage with the Atlantic market in ways which reinforced rather than undermined their sovereignty. The nations of the Iroquois Confederacy used European goods to construct a visually distinct political identity, while at the same time reducing women’s daily labor by outsourcing the creation of basic clothing items to European workers throughout the Atlantic world.
[SLIDE 3 – 1710 KINGS]
The emphasis on the damage done by trade to Native communities often follows from a focus on the masculinized space of the frontier diplomatic encounter and a corresponding absence of women. These two images typify portrayals of Iroquois men in both the documentary and visual record. In 1710, Hendrick on the left, and Peter on the right, visited London on a diplomatic mission, and had their portraits painted while there. Their mixed clothing marks them as what scholars have called the hybrid intercultural mediator, a male diplomat whose ability to move between Native and European worlds was advertised in his clothing. Together they represent the two main European understandings of how Native people incorporated trade during the eighteenth century. Hendrick is dressed in the staid black suit of a prosperous merchant or sober diplomat, holding a wampum belt that had already come to symbolize Indian diplomacy and peace making in the English mind by 1710, with a small hatchet symbolically laid to rest at his feet. Peter, on the right, wears almost nothing besides his open shirt stripped and folded nearly to a toga and a gun, emphasizing his tattoos and the scene of hunting in the background. In direct counterpoint to Hendrick, he represents the non-diplomatic option: the savage whose use of European clothing only emphasizes his savagery, highlighting his distance from the English viewer and the possibility of English warfare with their at-times fickle Iroquois allies who had nearly destroyed the colony of New France in the seventeenth century.
Depictions like these, in which European anxieties and ambitions were projected onto Native actors, abound in the archival record. This is doubly so in the case of Native women, who were often simply written out of existence. Much of the written record documenting Iroquois history comes from the minutes of Iroquois-European treaty councils, occupied by male diplomats like Hendrick and Peter. Women attended treaty councils and clan matrons directed the speeches and votes of chiefs behind closed doors, but in European recordings of the proceedings these women were simply not recorded, or recorded as a faceless number: ninety old women present. One thousand women and children. Women, children, and horses besides.
[SLIDE 4 – ACCOUNT BOOK]
One of the few places where Iroquois women do frequently appear is traders’ accountbooks. This is one was kept by the trader Jelles Fonda at Canajoharie, just west of Albany—Jelles is, yes, the ancestor of Henry, Peter and Jane Fonda. Accountbooks are odd and difficult sorts of records to work with because they’re sort of like itemized credit card receipts—they tell you who bought what, from whom, for how much, and sometimes if you’re lucky who it was for, but they don’t tell you much about what anyone thought about their purchase. Sawistowa bought many of the same items her white neighbors also bought from Fonda, but she likely used them in ways her white neighbors likely found unfamiliar and possibly disturbing. Elsewhere in the accountbook, Sawistowa bought a coat for her grandson, but what did she do with the gartering? Who was the fine white shirt and blanket for? Did she drink tea with the set of porcelain cups she bought a year later, or was it for something else?
Some of the most general things we can determine just from looking at this one entry: Iroquois women had their own accounts with a trader separate from their husbands and other male relatives, unlike contemporary European women and Native women of other nations. In seventeenth, eighteenth, and nineteenth century accountbooks, Iroquois women consistently made up half of all Native customers, a much higher proportion than European or other Native women, who usually traded under their husbands’ names if they were named by the trader at all.
Traders like Fonda complained bitterly that Indian women were as “neat and particular” as any lady of fashion in London, and cautioned their European suppliers to send only the best and finest quality cloth, lest they be unable to sell it. “They have a fancy and genius for inventing new fashions,” one trader wrote, expecting calicoes with dark grounds and light flowers one year, the next light colored grounds with multicolored stripes. Some Iroquois preferences were steady enough to become well known in Britain and France: the red blankets worn by Hendrick and Peter were so synonymous with the Indian trade that one weaver in rural England wrote in his daybook that he heard there was money to be made in weaving red strouds for the Indian trade—but only if the list, or colored edge of the fabric that Iroquois buyers preferred to be woven with a black or blue stripe, was the correct width. He didn’t know the correct style or width of the list, but he was determined to find out because he heard there was so much money to be made weaving for the Indian trade. Iroquois consumer preferences were such a significant force in the Atlantic market that even producers in rural England who had never heard of New York changed their practices to accommodate Iroquois tastes.
To make her purchases, Sawistowa paid in a combination of corn and cash. Earlier in the eighteenth century, she might have paid with a combination of small peltry and beaver furs, but as the eighteenth century progressed and the white population around Albany grew and urbanized, Iroquois women increasingly sold grain and produce. This earned Iroquoia the reputation as one of the most plentiful and easily cultivated areas of North America, a reputation as an agricultural paradise that would make Iroquois women’s farms targets during the American Revolution. And although the means by which Iroquois families purchased goods changed over the course of the century, the products with which they paid were women’s work. In the seventeen and early eighteenth centuries, women’s work trapped small animals and tanned, heavy beaver, moose and bear pelts, and in the late eighteenth century, women owned the fields and orchards that paid for goods.
[SLIDE 5 – CHARTS]
Long term trends like these are easiest to see by aggregating many accounts like Sawistowa’s over time and comparing them both for change over time within communities and between communities. This is a comparison of three accountbooks across the late seventeenth and early eighteenth century. The final one on the far right is Jelles Fonda’s that we just looked at. This is a comparison of how much Mohawk, Seneca, Mahican and European customers spent on different types of goods. At the top are goods typically associated with the fur trade, alcohol in red and guns, powder and lead shot in orange. In purple is miscellaneous items like bread, tea cups, bibles, horse saddles, pocket watches and other items. Light blue includes lengths of cloth like you might buy from the fabric store, while dark blue is ready-to-wear wear items. Ready to wear includes things like blankets, white linen shirts and men’s tailored coats like we saw on Hendrick and Peter Brant earlier, as well as “stockings,” folded pieces of wool cloth tied at the knee that were sewn in trade centers like Albany, Montreal, and Springfield specifically for the Indian trade. Ready made stockings and shirts were in such high demand that city governments as far away as Boston employed widows in sewing them for sale to the Iroquois as a form of poor relief. Cloth and clothing was such an important part of the fur trade that it might as well be called the cloth trade: for some Iroquois groups like the Mohawk it made up more than 80% of the value of all goods purchased from European traders.
Within the Iroquois Confederacy, buying trends differed significantly between groups and over time. In the late seventeenth century, the Seneca fought a war of attrition against New France to the North and experienced repeated attacks on their villages which made travel for trade unsafe, and what trade there was was to buy powder and shot. More eastern nations of the Confederacy like the Mohawk didn’t participate in this war, buying ready to wear items like Hendrick’s tailored coats like as part of their diplomatic courtship of the English. After 1690, peace between the Seneca and the French allowed for safe travel to Albany for the Seneca, and a drop in cloth prices increased the share of cloth as a percent of the total.
Other groups, like the nearby non-Iroquois Mahican who lived between Springfield and the Hudson River, purchased much less cloth and much more alcohol and subsistence items like bread and corn. This is one of the most telling signs that the narrative of Indians who sold their land for beads is actually a reverse of the truth: by about 1680, the Mahican had lost the majority of their land due to war, disease and fraudulent land sales, becoming trapped in a cycle of day labor and debt indenture to buy basic necessities like food and medical care. This pattern of high alcohol consumption and low clothing consumption doesn’t appear in accountbooks until after their landbase had been reduced, while the Iroquois pattern of majority cloth purchasing remained steady until the American Revolution. Native groups with a secure land base bought cloth, not alcohol, and didn’t go into debt for it, making the ability to purchase cloth and clothing in some ways a barometer of the impact of colonialism. In the late eighteenth century, Fonda’s Iroquois and European customers at Canajoharie bought cloth and clothing at similar rates from the same range of goods available, and yet Iroquois purchases were profoundly distressing to British government officials.
[SLIDE 6 – DECLARATION]
Throughout the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, French and British officials held out hope that selling clothing might be an avenue to converting and civilizing the militarily and diplomatically powerful Iroquois because European self-conceptions of civility was so rooted in markers signaled by clothing. As exemplified by this detail from the 1724 Declaration of Love held by the Williams College Museum of Art, European men’s clothing in the eighteenth century was all about restraint: staid colors, respectably plain fabrics, and restraint of the lower, natural, impulses of the body. Women’s clothing likewise restrained the body while decorating the person with light colors and fabrics, drawing attention to stark gender binaries and the divide between domestic and political. Throughout the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, both British and French government officials and missionaries repeatedly expressed hopes that Iroquois use of European clothing would lead to conformity with ideals of civility which were seen as prerequisites for Christian conversion and European political legitimacy. These hopes ran so high that after Hendrick and Peter Brant’s 1710 visit to London, a broadside circulated in England for the next eighty years telling the tale of the English noblewoman who saw Peter wearing a borrowed English coat and was so struck with his handsomeness that they promised to marry as soon as Peter converted to Christianity. This didn’t actually happen, but it’s an intriguing gender reversal of the Pocahontas story, with Indian man seen as a fit husband for an English woman once he converted materially and spiritually.
In reality, Europeans were deeply, deeply disturbed by what they saw as the alien remixture of what they thought of as stable signifiers of civilization into the markers of a wholly unfamiliar Native identity. At a treaty conference one French official wrote, “Imagine shirts powdered red, a waistcoat with tinsel glazing, a laced coat unbuttoned, a cap untied, and sometimes a wig put on wrong side before, joined with a face to which a Venetian mask could not compare in singularity, and you will have an idea of the costume of an Indian.” One English trader wrote that “they buy nothing from us but they take the shirts and first paint them before wearing them, the men not removing them til they turn black.” Women cut the fine silver buttons from purchased coats and sewed them as decorations for skirts or tied them at the knee, embroidering stockings, blankets, and coats with purchased ribbon, beads and gartering. All together, this remixture of imported items created an Iroquois whole from European parts.
Iroquois consumers did this because it was cheap: to make a set of clothing for one adult required six to eight deer, but two could purchase the same garments in cloth. That’s a third to a quarter less labor in hunting, tanning, preparing, and sewing, more so if you consider that many of the garments were purchased ready made. After 1690, peace treaties and increased white settlement on the frontiers of Iroquoia made long distance travel for trade safe and brought cloth prices down. Rather than destroying traditional Native culture, purchased clothing allowed Iroquois women to spend more time and resources on creating a distinctly Indian identity, decorating and embellishing an Indian self with European materials. Over the course of the eighteenth century, in written descriptions and in extant objects, we see a huge increase in beaded and sewn decorations of Iroquois clothing because Iroquois women were spending so much less time making the clothing itself. By the late eighteenth century, Jelles Fonda’s Iroquois customers bought more cloth yardage than ready-to-wear clothing in part because it was to be reworked as distinctly Iroquois items of dress.
This separation between neighboring Iroquois and European communities who purchased cloth and clothing from the same traders was visible in both what people wore and their social relations. This
[SLIDE 7 – NETWORK]
is the Anglican congregation that Jelles Fonda and his Iroquois customers attended at Canajoharie. I made this visualization from the church’s baptismal register, and I’m happy to talk a bit more about the methodology behind this or how I teach this kind of analysis in my digital methods class during the Q&A. Pink dots represent women, blue dots represent men, and the connections between them are ties of godparentage: when a child was baptized, the minister recorded the parents’ names along with the four to six godparents and witnesses they selected, creating new kinship ties between the parents, godparents, and witnesses through their ties to the child. This whole thing taken together looks like a mess, but it shows some interesting patterns in cultural differences between women’s social ties.
The 750 individuals in this congregation attended church together, worked together, and bought the same items from traders like Jelles Fonda, and yet culturally they remained distinct in their clothing and social practices. Most notably, in the large Dutch/English portion of the network, women were deeply enmeshed in a heterogenous network of male and female relations, while in this ethnic Scots subcommunity, men primarily had ties with men and formed the primary connection to the English network, and in the ethnic Palatine German community the internal ties are heterogenous but the external ties to the English community is still primarily through men.
This stands in pretty stark contrast with the Iroquois community at Canajoharie, which is connected to the English community only through two bridges here and here. Within the Iroquois community, ties between women and between women and men are much more prevalent than ties between men, reflecting the matrifocal character of Iroquois families despite Christian conversion. Within the Iroquois community, women formed bridges between little family clusters, joining multiple families even as the Iroquois community at Canajoharie moved towards a nuclear family model of residence. This kind of pattern can also be found in accountbook networks like the ones we looked at earlier and church registers into the nineteenth century, suggesting that this is a distinctly Iroquois pattern that continued despite pressures for conversion and acculturation.
I chose to show you this network instead of one of the accountbook networks because it also shows the position of male diplomats in the day-to-day experience of cultural entanglement. Michael Montour, here, and Sir William Johnson, here, were both intercultural mediators who supposedly moved between two worlds like the hybrid figures Hendrick and Peter we looked at earlier. Michael Montour was a half-Mohawk translator who lived with his Mohawk mother and wife and who shared ties of godparentage with a Dutch female trader Anna Clement; Sir William Johnson was the British Superintendent for Indian Affairs whose most recent biography called him “the White Savage,” to give you an idea of how he’s been portrayed in the literature. Montour and Johnson are the kind of male diplomats who the academic literature primarily focuses on as the main actors in Native-European interaction, because they’re the kind of figure who show up in written accounts of diplomacy and other formal affairs. And yet, to look at their relationships through the lens of their economic and kinship ties, their position in their communities becomes much more complicated.
Even more difficult to reconstruct are social ties like this one, between Jacamine Kagh-ter-eni, Margaret Tehon-wagh-wan-geragh-kwa, and an otherwise unrecorded Dutch family. None of these people appear in any other written records, and yet here they form one of two main bridges between the Iroquois and European communities at Canajoharie. In simply reading the church register, these bridges aren’t immediately evident, but in a social network visualization like this it becomes clear who maintained cross-cultural connections in this mixed race church. Women like Jacamine, Margaret, and Anna Clement made up the majority of cross-cultural interactions in day-to-day life as evidenced in networks across the seventeenth, eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, which puts the politics of Native-European interaction in early America in a much more domestic light.
[SLIDE 8 – SCHOOL]
The centrality of women’s work in creating and maintaining a stubbornly Iroquois identity was a central point of anxiety for British, French, and later American officials. This anxiety drove the creation of schools like this one in Seneca country, established by the American Board of Commissioners of Foreign Missionaries founded here at Williams. From the early seventeenth century through the late nineteenth century, settler governments in New York, New France, Connecticut and Massachusetts funded the creation of schools explicitly for the conversion of Iroquois communities. The thing all of these schools had in common was their aim to teach specifically Iroquois girls and women to spin, weave, sew, and knit European and American style clothing, rather than purchase items and embellish them as they had for, by 1800, two centuries. Some of these schools opened with the original goal of educating Native boys in Hebrew, Latin and Greek to send them back to their communities as missionaries and preachers, but when the converted and educated boys went out to preach, they wrote back that they were unable to maintain the standards of material civility which they had become accustomed to without a wife. Alone and relying on the hospitality of Iroquois women, these young Native preachers wrote that they were reduced to the same clothing which they had been taught equated savagery and heathenism, and abandoned their missions. It was an impossible expectation for white missionaries to maintain themselves in Indian communities without a wife, they wrote, so why should Native missionaries be any different. And so conversion efforts centered on girls and women as the foundation of family civility for much of the seventeenth, eighteenth, and nineteenth centuries, laying the groundwork for the later boarding school system.
Both before and after the American Revolution, Iroquois communities were intensely aware of the restrictions to their political independence which economic dependance and material and religious conversion would entail, shaped by their observance of their Native American non-Iroquois neighbors like the Mahican we looked at earlier, as well as their observance of hierarchies of race and labor among their European neighbors. The Iroquois had sought out literacy in European languages from the early seventeenth century, as British and American officials began to pressure for more total regimes of agricultural and economic change in the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, Iroquois leaders pushed back.
In Iroquois governance, all-male councils of sachems met and negotiated with outsiders at treaty conferences, while all-female councils of clan matrons met separately to appoint sachems, provision war parties, and decide divisions of land. To communicate the council of matrons’ decisions, a male “speaker for the women” spoke to the male council of sachems, and these speakers for the women became increasingly visible at treaty conferences in the late eighteenth century as the council of matrons protested European incursions.
In 1770, one Seneca speaker for the women, Onghwandekha, warned against allowing a Christian missionary school like the one pictured here. Onghwandekha asked, “how many remnants of tribes to the East are so reduced, that they pound sticks to make brooms [for the white people] in order to purchase a loaf of Bread or perhaps a shirt. . . This will be the condition of our children in a short time if we change or renounce our religion for that of the white people. . . . We shall be sunk so low as to hoe corn and squashes in the field, chop wood, stoop down and milk cows like slaves among the Dutch people.”1 Onghwandekha clearly outlined the low status of racialized manual labor divorced from landownership, and the connections between Euro-american religious “civility” suggested by the quotes from Exodus and Proverbs here, and the reorientation of Iroquois labor it required. Although Iroquois women already hoed corn and squashes, and occasionally even milked their own cows, it was Iroquois women who controlled the product of their own country and as Onghwandekha said, “it was they that made the men.” Loss of land and day work or forced labor on land owned by whites, Onghwandekha argued, would entrap Iroquois communities in a cycle of debt and dependance like it had the Mahican and enslaved Africans.
Americans were very aware of this as well, which is why American attacks on Iroquois property during the Revolutionary War focused on destruction of Iroquois fields and orchards, as well as theft of clothing and consumer goods, a combined denial of landownership and participation in material civility. When early 19th century Americans like ABCFM missionaries pressured Iroquois reservation communities to learn to spin, weave and sew their own clothing or face removal west, it meant dismantling a commercial culture which Iroquois people had been using for more than two hundred years to reinforce their political and cultural identity as Iroquois. Faced with the choice between removal or acceptance of an age of homespun which Laurel Thatcher Ulrich has argued was imaginary even for the white American communities which deployed it as a marker of political legitimacy, the Iroquois were forced into a position of accepting economic underdevelopment as the price of remaining on their New York reservations.
[SLIDE 9 – PARKER]
Tensions over women’s work, conversion, and the politics of clothing continued into the 19th century, when they became much more explicitly visible in Iroquois women’s work. This is Caroline Parker, an influential Seneca critic of removal and what would become the Dawes Act. The Dawes Act aimed to divide and sell off reservation lands of those Native nations, like the Iroquois, who were deemed by the federal government to be “civilized” enough to be folded into the white American population. The dress Parker is wearing here was not every-day wear—by 1848, when she made this dress, Iroquois women by and large wore clothing indistinguishable from their white neighbors. This outfit was created explicitly for the New York State Museum’s new Native American collection, and the anthropologist who commissioned it requested a set of men’s and women’s clothing made in the “most ancient and traditional style, with the finest materials available.”
Parker agreed to make the pieces, but when they arrived, the anthropologist was aghast and a bit scandalized that the overdress was of plain red cotton and the skirt of a plain blue wool. Hadn’t he provided enough funds for her to buy the silk and velvet that Iroquois women’s ceremonial regalia was typically made of? Parker declined to explain her choices to the anthropologist, but in a later letter to her brother she alluded to using her family’s portion of the red cotton cloth from the federal government’s annual treaty payment, though she didn’t say for what. The annuity payment, made in exchange for Iroquois land ceeded at the end of the American Revolution, was made partially in red cotton cloth to symbolize the ongoing commercial and diplomatic relations between the nations of the Iroquois and the new US federal government. By the 1830s and 40s, this red cotton cloth had become a charged symbol of broken treaty promises as the federal government allowed fraudulent land sales in contradiction to the treaty and backed a so-called “revolution” in Seneca government which resulted in a new constitution stripping clan matrons of the traditional powers to name and depose chiefs, barring Iroquois women from voting and a voice in their own communities’ politics for the first time in history. The land sales and removal of women was, not surprisingly, seen as intertwined, especially coming as it did during the same summer that abolitionists and women’s rights advocates met to discuss the Declaration of Sentiments at Seneca Falls.
Caroline’s dress is one of the most-viewed pieces of clothing in the world, having been on public display almost constantly in New York and around the world since 1848. An engraving of her photo was also published as the opening image to Lewis Henry Morgan’s League of the Iroquois, the study which laid the foundations for modern academic anthropology. Caroline’s dress, with its celestial tree, council fire, and sky dome beading symbolizing the Iroquois creation story of Sky Woman bringing all life to earth and teaching her sons to govern wisely and by consensus, has been enshrined as the definitively traditional version of Iroquois women’s dress without regard for its specifically political context and meaning. Most ironically of all, Caroline’s opposition to removal later in life made her a prominent enough figure for her to be portrayed—during her own lifetime—by white women in “historical pageants” alongside semi-historical figures like Pocahontas, Hiawatha, Nokomis and Minnehaha. Her dress was iconic enough to be worn in this pageant to represent her, and yet it even during her lifetime it was divorced enough from its political meaning that it was used in pageants to raise money supporting US Army units charged with removing western Native groups to reservations.
Moments like these, in which Native and non-Native people retold narratives to the past in order to make claims of ownership in the present, led me to my second project on race and narratives of time. Right now my second projects involves three parts and I’m happy to talk a bit more about this in the Q&A: the first, on seventeenth and eighteenth narratives of the peopling of the Americas, the second, on conflict over nineteenth and twentieth century hobby archaeology of indigenous graves, and the third, on modern narratives of early American history in political rhetoric, videogames, TV, textbooks, and hobby historical reenacting. These three pieces are linked by narratives of the early American past that try to define whose past it is, which is both a politically and racially charged question. The after life of Caroline Parker’s dress led me to these questions about how early American history has been told as a daily practice, in which narratives of an originary past are used to construct a self-fulfilling claim to land and political legitimacy in the present.
[SLIDE 9 – MOHAWK WOMAN]
In both the present and the eighteenth century, an image like this one is decidedly political: it represents both the politics of self-creation and the politics of colonial erasure. This simple little watercolor is literally “Europe and the People Without History.” Posed coquettishly in a settingless background, this woman and her baby are divorced from any personal or historical context which might help us understand her as anything but a character in a European pastoral scene. Her anonymity is typical of many Native women in the historical record left by European observers, in which Native peoples’ choices and agency were flattened and described only in the most general terms, if at all. Almost everything the woman is shown wearing was manufactured in Europe and purchased from a European trader, much of it also made by a white seamstress but embellished after purchase by an Iroquois seamstress. The slippage between European cloth and Iroquois clothing could be, and has been, interpreted from a colonial vantage as an erasure of Iroquois material culture by European manufacturing and trade.
And yet, triangulated through the lens of other evidence like the social separatism of the converted Iroquois congregation at Canajoharie, European anxiety over the significance of Iroquois religious and material conversion, and Iroquois buying patterns, it becomes clear that Iroquois women used clothing to position themselves and their families in larger regional and global networks of power. At the heart of Iroquois communities’ domestic decision making away from the frontiers of contact with settler colonies, these women’s choices shaped the economic and political face their nations presented to the world. In a period most copiously recorded from a European or American perspective, looking at the significance of everyday clothing allows us to look at how women in structured their labor; rejected and remade colonialist signifiers; and invited and directed the impact of global trade in their local contexts. And yet because it was domestic and prosaic, because it was women’s work, it has gone largely ignored as political work. Like Caroline Parker’s dress, Iroquois women’s consumer choices have been divorced of their political meanings because women’s work can be political, or it can be domestic, but it can rarely be both. In the study of Native women, this has meant that they have often been invisible as historical actors because their only visible work has been domestic work. The politics of consumerism in early America were the politics of identity and self-creation, both domestic and political.